From its initial identification in 1937, West Nile virus
lived unobtrusively in Asia and Africa, causing a mild,
flulike illness. Then, in the late 1990s, it abruptly spread
to Eastern Europe. In 1999 it made its American debut in
New York.
Based on experience to date, public-health officials estimate
that 80 percent of people infected with the virus have no
symptoms and never know they've had it. Almost all the rest
come down with a syndrome called West Nile fever: a fever
accompanied by headache, weakness, and sometimes nausea
or a skin rash.
For most people, the syndrome lasts a few days and then
they recover, and presumably have long-term immunity to
the virus. A small share of those who are infected, about
1 in 150, becomes desperately ill. Doctors know that the
risk of getting a really bad case of West Nile rises precipitously
with age. Infected children rarely show ill effects. Most
who get seriously ill are over 50. People whose immune system
has been suppressed by chemotherapy or other causes are
also at higher risk.
Beyond that, "we have no idea why one 50-year-old
who becomes infected remains asymptomatic while another
one is devastated," says Arturo Leis, M.D., a neurologist
at Methodist Rehabilitation Center in Jackson, Miss. Leis
has cared for many gravely ill West Nile patients.
Severe West Nile disease can take several forms, all of
them dangerous. Most of the first known victims had encephalitis
or meningitis, an inflammation of the brain or its lining,
as well as fever and extreme weakness. So far, about 10
percent of severely affected victims in the U.S. have died;
the vast majority of them were in their 70s or 80s.
Last summer, case reports in Louisiana and Mississippi
documented the existence of another frightening variety
of severe West Nile disease with polio-like symptoms. The
patients experienced complete paralysis of one or more limbs,
resulting from the virus' destruction of critical motor-neuron
cells. But unlike the encephalitis victims, who tended to
be in their 70s or 80s, most of the paralytic cases occurred
in people in their 50s or sometimes 40s. To date, none have
recovered. "The prognosis is very similar to polio,"
Dr. Leis says. "All the patients remain profoundly
weak."
At the moment, there
is no effective treatment for West Nile disease other than
to keep victims comfortable. A vaccine is years away. Blood-collecting
agencies hope to have a test in use by this summer's mosquito
season that will screen for the virus in the blood supply.
BIRDS
INFECTED BY MOSQUITOES
Dead birds are often the first clue that the virus is in
the neighborhood. West Nile "is really a bird disease
that extends to people through infected mosquitoes,"
says Lyle Petersen, M.D., deputy director of the CDC's division
of vector-borne infectious diseases. When the weather warms
enough to prompt infected female mosquitoes to wake up from
hibernation, they start hunting for the blood meals they
need to lay eggs. They bite birds and infect them with the
virus; the birds then pass the virus on to other mosquitoes
that bite them.
"The whole cycle escalates, and by the late summer,
there are so many birds and mosquitoes infected that human
outbreaks occur," Petersen says.
The hardest-hit birds are the corvids: crows, magpies,
jays, and ravens. "In the New York City area, by August
or September 1999 and 2000, over 90 percent of dead crows
turned in for testing were positive," says Robert G.
McLean, Ph.D., program manager for wildlife diseases at
the U.S. Department of Agriculture's National Wildlife Research
Center in Fort Collins, Colo. "It's unreal; I've never
seen a virus that severe."
New CDC research has shown that birds can also get infected
just by sharing a roost with other infected birds or by
eating infected birds and other animals. It's important
not to touch any dead bird or animal you encounter.
As for mosquitoes, biologists are confident they've fingered
the major species carrying the West Nile virus: the closely
related regional members of the genus Culex. In the
Northeast, it's Culex pipiens, the northern house
mosquito; in the Southeast, Culex quinquefasciatas; and
in the West, Culex tarsalis.
"They're called house mosquitoes for a reason,"
Petersen says. "They like to hang out in sheltered
areas like houses and live quite happily in an urban environment."
Culex are readily infected by the virus. And they
spread the disease because they bite birds, people, and
other animals.
While West Nile is
the most widespread mosquito-borne disease in the U.S.,
it's not the only one. Other types of encephalitis, including
St. Louis encephalitis, eastern equine encephalitis, and
LaCrosse encephalitis, break out periodically, though never
with the frequency of West Nile virus. Even the malaria
parasite, which hasn't been endemic in the U.S. since 1970,
occasionally shows up in someone in this country who has
not traveled abroad.
PROTECTING
HOUSE AND YARD
The key to keeping mosquitoes out of your house and yard
is denying the females comfortable places to lay their eggs.
It takes energy for mosquitoes to fly. If you're breeding
them in your yard, you're the first one they're going to
bite, say mosquito-control experts.
House mosquitoes are drawn to muddy, murky bodies of water.
Keep your yard and house free of containers filled with
standing water and you've won half the battle.
Keep
your rain gutters scrupulously clean; Culex mosquitoes
are partial to waterlogged, decaying leaves.
Don't
allow water to accumulate for more than a few days in any
container. Mosquitoes can multiply in untended dog bowls,
birdbaths, birdfeeders that collect water, saucers under
flowerpots, wheelbarrows, children's wading pools, and the
water that collects in swimming-pool covers. However, mosquitoes
will not breed in above-ground or in-ground swimming pools
that are kept clean and properly chlorinated.
Indoors,
if you see a mosquito, kill it immediately. You can swat
it with your hand without fear; it takes an actual bite
to transmit West Nile virus. "Culex like to
get inside the house," says Ray Parsons, Ph.D., director
of mosquito control for Harris County, Texas, which includes
the Houston area. "And once they do, there's nothing
they can feed on except a person or a pet."
Research
shows that dogs don't get sick when infected with West Nile
virus, and cats get a brief, mild illness at worst. Neither
is likely to transmit the disease.
Electric
mosquito traps catch and kill some mosquitoes outdoors,
but are not safe indoors. Our May 2003 report on
mosquito traps will help you decide whether this costly
device makes sense for your yard.
PREVENTING
BITES
The most effective way to avoid bites is to stay inside
when mosquitoes are active. For Culex and most mosquitoes,
that means at dusk and throughout the evening.
If you must go out then, wear light-colored, loose-fitting
clothing that covers as much of your skin as comfort permits.
Mosquitoes will bite right through tight-fitting fabrics.
Avoid perfumes and aftershaves, which attract some mosquitoes.
Wear a repellent on
exposed skin--ideally, one with protection lasting no longer
than the time you're going to be out. A list of products
we've tested for effectiveness at repelling mosquitoes can
be found in our May 2003 report on
insect repellents. See
Safe use of insect repellents for advice on how to use
repellents safely.
SPRAYS:
WHEN ALL ELSE FAILS
Mosquito spraying is strictly a local affair. Some regions,
typically ones that have longstanding mosquito problems,
have permanent areawide mosquito-control programs. In other
places, including large cities such as Chicago, Cleveland,
and New York, the job of mosquito control falls on the local
health department. No matter who's in charge, they have
broad discretion on how to go about the job. In so doing,
they must balance the danger of infection with West Nile
against the risks of spraying, such as potential harm to
health and the environment.
Regardless of local conditions, however, all good mosquito-spraying
programs have certain things in common:
The
choice of when and where to spray should be based on constant
surveillance and monitoring of West Nile in birds, mosquitoes,
and people. Ideally, spraying should target populations
of mosquitoes after they have tested positive for the virus
but before they have infected any people.
Residents
should get plenty of warning about when and where spraying
will take place, and which pesticides will be used. During
spraying and for several hours afterward, people should
stay inside with their windows and doors closed to allow
time for the pesticides to disperse and break down. Families
should bring outdoor toys inside before the spraying. Asthmatics
should be especially cautious, since the sprays can set
off asthma attacks in susceptible people.
Spraying
should use the least-toxic pesticides. In most cases, the
preferred choice is one of the synthetic pyrethroids, fast-acting
compounds that break down quickly once they're sprayed.
They are thousands of times more toxic to insects than to
people (though they are toxic to fish and bees). Some widely
used products in this category include permethrin, resmethrin,
and sumithrin.
Last September 2002, scientists from the CDC's National
Center for Environmental Health conducted a study of 193
people who lived in areas of Mississippi that had been sprayed
for mosquito control with people who lived elsewhere. The
researchers measured the amount of pyrethroid pesticide-breakdown
products in the test subjects' urine samples, and they found
no difference in levels between the two groups.
Programs
should avoid using the pesticides malathion and naled, even
though the Environmental Protection Agency (which regulates
pesticides nationwide) has approved them for mosquito control.
Both are organophosphates, a type of pesticide capable of
impairing the function of a vital nervous-system enzyme
called cholinesterase. In addition, insect-control experts
say, mosquitoes rapidly develop resistance to malathion.